| Rank | Butts | Total |
| 1 | Buckwheat BBQ | 15.6571 |
| 2 | All Smoked Up | 15.5857 |
| 3 | Ultimate Tailgaters BBQ | 15.4286 |
| 4 | Big Butts BBQ Gang | 15.3429 |
| 5 | S’Lowcountry Q | 15.1583 |
| 6 | Swine Time | 15.1429 |
| 7 | Pig Daddys BBQ | 15.0071 |
| 8 | Allnighters | 14.9857 |
| 9 | Doko Smoke BBQ | 14.9250 |
| 10 | Elite BBQ Smokers | 14.6333 |
| 11 | Big Boy BBQ | 14.5333 |
| 12 | Smokin, Esso B’s | 14.3143 |
| 13 | Pork Q Pine | 13.8714 |
| 14 | Smokin’ Brothers BBQ | 13.4917 |
| Butts | Appearance | Aroma | Texture / Tenderness | Taste | Overall Impression |
| Buckwheat BBQ | 2.8143 | 1.7429 | 4.6429 | 4.6571 | 1.8000 |
| All Smoked Up | 2.8000 | 1.7714 | 4.6000 | 4.6286 | 1.7857 |
| Ultimate Tailgaters BBQ | 2.7857 | 1.7429 | 4.5714 | 4.6143 | 1.7143 |
| Big Butts BBQ Gang | 2.7286 | 1.6571 | 4.6571 | 4.5429 | 1.7571 |
| S’Lowcountry Q | 2.6417 | 1.7167 | 4.4583 | 4.5417 | 1.8000 |
| Swine Time | 2.6571 | 1.6857 | 4.5714 | 4.5143 | 1.7143 |
| Pig Daddys BBQ | 2.6857 | 1.6643 | 4.5000 | 4.4714 | 1.6857 |
| Allnighters | 2.6429 | 1.7214 | 4.4857 | 4.4857 | 1.6500 |
| Doko Smoke BBQ | 2.6667 | 1.7167 | 4.3833 | 4.5000 | 1.6583 |
| Elite BBQ Smokers | 2.6333 | 1.6500 | 4.4167 | 4.3000 | 1.6333 |
| Big Boy BBQ | 2.5667 | 1.6000 | 4.3333 | 4.3667 | 1.6667 |
| Smokin, Esso B’s | 2.3714 | 1.4714 | 4.4857 | 4.3857 | 1.6000 |
| Pork Q Pine | 2.2429 | 1.6286 | 4.2286 | 4.2000 | 1.5714 |
| Smokin’ Brothers BBQ | 2.3500 | 1.5167 | 4.0667 | 4.0667 | 1.4917 |