| Rank | Butts | Total |
| 1 | Smokin’ Stacks | 15.8425 |
| 2 | Blowin’ Smoke | 15.7563 |
| 3 | Buckwheats BBQ | 15.5513 |
| 4 | Red Cup Q | 15.4900 |
| 5 | All Smoked Up | 15.4475 |
| 6 | Ledyards BarBQue Company | 15.3650 |
| 7 | Palmetto Smokehouse | 15.2063 |
| 8 | Bold Branch Bar-B-Que Boys | 15.0713 |
| 9 | Beast BBQ | 14.7750 |
| 10 | T’s Bar | 14.4588 |
| Butts | Appearance | Aroma | Texture / Tenderness | Taste | Overall Impression |
| Smokin’ Stacks | 2.8188 | 1.8063 | 4.7063 | 4.6750 | 1.8363 |
| Blowin’ Smoke | 2.8250 | 1.7625 | 4.6500 | 4.6875 | 1.8313 |
| Buckwheats BBQ | 2.7813 | 1.7813 | 4.5625 | 4.6438 | 1.7825 |
| Red Cup Q | 2.7750 | 1.7250 | 4.6125 | 4.5875 | 1.7900 |
| All Smoked Up | 2.7875 | 1.7875 | 4.5500 | 4.5750 | 1.7475 |
| Ledyards BarBQue Company | 2.7375 | 1.7375 | 4.5500 | 4.5875 | 1.7525 |
| Palmetto Smokehouse | 2.7688 | 1.6563 | 4.6063 | 4.4313 | 1.7438 |
| Bold Branch Bar-B-Que Boys | 2.7250 | 1.7250 | 4.4688 | 4.4438 | 1.7088 |
| Beast BBQ | 2.5375 | 1.6375 | 4.4750 | 4.4625 | 1.6625 |
| T’s Bar | 2.4313 | 1.6375 | 4.4188 | 4.3500 | 1.6213 |